Share This Article
This year, the Sudbury Housing Trust applied for $900,000 in Community Preservation Act (CPA) funds to create more affordable homes. At the Community Preservation Committee’s (CPC) Nov. 12 meeting, Trust Vice Chair Jack Ryan explained that the money is the difference between the Trust creating one more house or enough houses to give local residents and workers a preference. Several CPC members questioned whether the full amount is needed.
Ryan told the CPC “What we’re trying to drive home here is it’s all about the numbers, and it’s all about making local preference available.”
One House Two House Old House New House
Ryan opened by saying he wanted to correct figures that had circulated on social media. The Trust’s cash balance is $1,274,000, he said, after the recent purchase of 16 Stone Road. That house is in the state’s affordability program but has not yet sold; the Trust expects roughly $350,000 back when it does sell.
A single purchase requires $800,000 to $900,000 on hand, Ryan said. Qualifying homes are listing for $750,000 to $850,000, and many need a roof, heating work or a new furnace before they can be resold as affordable.
“That’s the reason I started the conversation by saying that we have $1,274,000 in our account,” he said. “That would give us the money for one affordable house right now.”
That is where local preference comes in. Under state rules, Ryan explained, a Town can reserve homes for local-preference buyers only if those homes make up less than 70% of the units offered at the same time. Local preference would cover current residents, people who work in Sudbury, such as teachers, police, firefighters and DPW staff, and, Ryan emphasized, the families of METCO students in Sudbury schools. A single home goes to a statewide lottery.
“If you have one house, you can’t use local preference, because making it local preference would be 100%. That’s not less than 70%,” he said. “If you have two houses, one of them could be local preference.”
With $900,000 from the CPC plus the Stone Road proceeds, Ryan said, the Trust would have a little over $2 million, which “means we’ve definitely got enough for 2, and maybe we could stretch to 3.” Each affordable home resells for about $350,000, he said, giving the Trust a head start on future years.
The Trust is also looking for cheaper routes. It is running tests on 77 Hudson Road, a Town-owned parcel west of the fire station, where Habitat for Humanity could possibly help with a new build. Ryan cautioned that that parcel was very wet, and was still being evaluated. Transferring the land would require Select Board and Town Meeting approval. He said the Trust expects an option on 213 Haynes Road, at the entrance to Liberty Ledge, and has walked away from three other properties because buying them was not financially responsible.
How Much Is Enough?
Select Board member Dan Carty, who represents that board on the CPC, ran his own math. Add $300,000 from Stone Road and another $300,000 from the CPC to the current balance, he said, and the Trust would have $1.874 million. He pointed out that was more than $900,000 per house, and sufficient for two houses.
Ryan said he would use a total closer to $1.6 million. Two homes at that level would work “maybe if you can do both for $8[00,000], but if you can’t, then no,” he said.
CPC Chair Sam Markuse offered a middle figure: two homes at $900,000 each plus a $250,000 buffer for testing and operating costs comes to about $2.05 million, roughly $450,000 more than the Trust would have once Stone Road sells.
“My point is, I don’t think we need $900,000 to get to enough for two houses,” Carty said.
Carty also challenged Ryan’s statement that the Trust cannot borrow. Earlier, when Park and Recreation Commission representative Granger Atkeson asked whether the Trust had considered using a mortgage to bridge a purchase, Ryan answered, “Can’t do that. We can’t get a mortgage… We have to have the money up front.” He said having cash in hand is how the Trust won 16 Stone Road: “When the conversation occurred in the driveway of that house with the realtor, we basically said, we have the cash right now to buy the house.”
“Housing trusts absolutely can borrow money,” Carty said. With Select Board approval, he said, the Trust can borrow against what it has, and beyond that it needs a two-thirds Town Meeting vote. “Fact check me on that, but I’m 99% sure.” The Trust’s declaration, adopted at the 2023 Annual Town Meeting, does allow borrowing on those terms (Sudbury General Bylaws).
Track Record
Carty later questioned how central the Trust has been to the Town’s affordable housing count. During the last 10 years the Trust created no new units, he claimed, and Sudbury’s affordable share rose from about 5% to almost 12%.
CPC member Sherrill Cline, who represents the Sudbury Housing Authority, said, “I’m not sure that’s accurate.”
Carty doubled down after some back and forth. “What I’m saying is factually correct. So without any contribution from the Housing Trust, our affordable housing stock went up significantly.”
That statement is not correct.
In 2019 the Sudbury Housing Trust contributed to the creation of 56 affordable units during phase 2 of the Coolidge project on Boston Post Road. The Housing Trust contributed $250,000 to the project. Here’s the Massachusetts Housing Partnership summary of phrase 2 and the funding sources.
Town Meeting appropriated another $320,000 of CPA funding to the same project. In the presentation of the article, it was noted that this project would keep “Sudbury above the 10% Subsidized Housing Inventory until at least 2030 Census.”
While it’s clear the Sudbury Housing Trust played a central role in getting the Town over the 10% threshhold, affordable unit creation is just one of several functions of the Trust, and home purchases are just one of several ways the Trust can help create affordable units. There wasn’t much conversation about the other ways the Trust supports housing affordability in Sudbury. They operate multiple programs, including a mortgage assistance program and a small grants program that helps qualifying residents pay for health and safety related repairs to the homes.
During Covid, the Trust distributed more than $400,000 in rental assistance, and $75,000 each in mortgage assistance and small grants. The Trust also advocated for and secured American Rescue Plan Act funds to support some of those efforts. Here’s how they explained it when launching the Housing Roundtable series.
As the questions continued, Ryan cast the current request as a test of the town’s stated support. “What we are trying to do is take people in town at their word when they say, we want affordable housing, we just don’t want it here, or we don’t want it there, but we want affordable housing,” he said. “We’re saying we’ll get to work to find the places where it can be, but we need to have the finances in order to be able to do it.”
Local Preference
Carty then pressed on whether local preference is a real strategy or a selling point. The Trust bought Stone Road by itself, he noted. “We could have passed on Stone Road and waited for two houses to come on the market, right?”
“Listen, it’s all strategic moves. It’s a chess game,” Ryan replied. If a second house was not coming, he said, the Trust would proceed with one. He added “What concerns me is the idea of just saying, we’re not even going to make it possible for you to do that,” he said, characterizing that as “the Town not stepping forward, and that’s disappointing.”
Carty was not persuaded. “We heard it probably 3 or 4 times is local preference, local preference, local preference,” he said. “Is the plan then to do multiple units, or are we just going to take the next house that comes up on the market?”
He noted that properties discussed at the Trust’s meeting that morning had been turned down. “I’m not confident that we would get to the opportunity to purchase more than one house at a time, and I don’t necessarily think that that is a reason to… to try to sell this,” he said.
“I see a shaking head Jack,” Carty added.
“I am shaking my head. You’re right, you’re right I’m shaking my head. I’ll go on the record,” Ryan fired back.
Carty then began questioning Ryan about direct quotes from Ryan in a Housing Trust meeting that happened earlier that day. He wanted Ryan to explain a comment where he told Housing Trust Chair Carmine Gentile that he wanted to avoid taking a hard line position on the $900,000 request. Carty pressed Ryan to explain not what he said, but what the hypothetical opposite would look like. “So, what is that going to look like? That you taking a hard line…”
At first Ryan questioned the context of the quote, then he responded “My job here is to be an advocate for affordable housing, right? That is my job, to be an advocate for affordable housing. I am going to be an advocate for affordable housing.”
What’s Next
There will be more deliberation about all the project applications in the coming weeks. Then the CPC has to decide if they will recommend them to Town Meeting. The CPC doesn’t decide if a project is funded, it can only get the project onto the Town Meeting warrant.
The full meeting is below. The CPC takes up the Housing Trust application at the top of the meeting.

